Jacob Ealy and Nathan Smith added medals to the list in 2022.
Carlton Haselrig is the only person ever to win six NCAA titles in wrestling - three times in DII and three times in DI.
Three Pittsburgh-Johnstown wrestlers were two-time NCAA champions - Thad Benton, Jody Strittmatter, and Chris Eddins.
The wrestling program claimed the fifth most All-Americans in the country from 2010 to 2019!
The top ten wrestlers in Mountain Cats history won a total of thirteen NCAA titles and thirty-two medals.
They include a three-time champion, three two-time champions, and four four-time All-Americans.
Check out the best Pittsburgh-Johnstown wrestlers of all-time ranked by NCAA DII medals!
Here are the top ten!
Rank - Name - Year - Score - Medals
#1 - Carlton Haselrig - 1989 - 58 - 3,1,1,1
#2 - Mike Corcetti - 2008 - 42 - 4,2,4,2
#3 - Thad Benton - 2006 - 39 - 5,1,1
#4 - Travis McKillop - 2016 - 38 - 7,3,2,2
#5 - Troy Barbush - 1999 - 37 - 5,5,5,1
#5 - Shane Valko - 2010 - 37 - 4,2,1
#7 - John Strittmatter - 1999 - 35 - 2,5,1
#7 - Brandon Newill - 2002 - 35 - 3,4,1
#9 - Jody Strittmatter - 1999 - 32 - 1,1
#9 - Chris Eddins - 2019 - 32 - 1,1
There have been 83 All-American wrestlers who have won 149 DII medals in Pittsburgh-Johnstown history!
Check out the full list in this Rokfin exclusive!
Check out the full story from the photo!
Like and follow us on Facebook!
Subscribe on Rokfin for exclusive content!
Get your gear for this year!
Support Jersey Wrestling and become a sponsor!