| Weight | Place | Wrestler | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| 123 | 1st | Tony Gizoni | Waynesburg |
| 123 | 2nd | Bill Borders | Oklahoma |
| 123 | 3rd | Tom Keys | Oklahoma State |
| 123 | 4th | Tony Dragoin | Auburn |
| 130 | 1st | Walter Romanowski | Cornell Iowa |
| 130 | 2nd | Hal Moore | Oklahoma State |
| 130 | 3rd | Gene Lybbert | Northern Iowa |
| 130 | 4th | Jack Blubaugh | Oklahoma |
| 137 | 1st | George Layman | Oklahoma State |
| 137 | 2nd | Tommy Evans | Oklahoma |
| 137 | 3rd | Don Maurey | Penn State |
| 137 | 4th | Bob Hartman | Columbia |
| 147 | 1st | Keith Young | Northern Iowa |
| 147 | 2nd | Don Frey | Penn State |
| 147 | 3rd | Byron Todd | Oklahoma State |
| 147 | 4th | George Jackson | Oklahoma |
| 157 | 1st | Phil Smith | Oklahoma |
| 157 | 2nd | Fred McLean | Ohio State |
| 157 | 3rd | Don Govoni | Northern Colorado |
| 157 | 4th | Bob Mason | Wyoming |
| 167 | 1st | Gene Gibbons | Michigan State |
| 167 | 2nd | George Graveson | Yale |
| 167 | 3rd | Don Thomas | Navy |
| 167 | 4th | Ken Prihoda | Minnesota State |
| 177 | 1st | Grover Rains | Oklahoma State |
| 177 | 2nd | Mike Rubino | Penn State |
| 177 | 3rd | Dick Torio | Toledo |
| 177 | 4th | Bentley Lyon | California-Berkeley |
| UNL | 1st | Brad Glass | Princeton |
| UNL | 2nd | Homer Barr | Penn State |
| UNL | 3rd | Harry Lanzi | Toledo |
| UNL | 4th | Bill Miller | Ohio State |