| Weight | Place | Wrestler | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| 115 | 1st | Terry McCann | Iowa |
| 123 | 1st | Ed Peery | Pittsburgh |
| 130 | 1st | Myron Roderick | Oklahoma State |
| 137 | 1st | Jim Sinadinos | Michigan State |
| 147 | 1st | Eddie Eichelberger | Lehigh |
| 157 | 1st | Larry TenPas | Illinois |
| 167 | 1st | Ed DeWitt | Pittsburgh |
| 177 | 1st | Dan Hodge | Oklahoma |
| 191 | 1st | Ken Leuer | Iowa |
| UNL | 1st | Gordon Roesler | Oklahoma |