| Weight | Place | Wrestler | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| 125 | 1st | Troy Nickerson | Cornell |
| 133 | 1st | Frank Gomez | Michigan State |
| 141 | 1st | J Jaggers | Ohio State |
| 149 | 1st | Darrion Caldwell | North Carolina State |
| 157 | 1st | Jordan Burroughs | Nebraska |
| 165 | 1st | Jarrod King | Edinboro |
| 174 | 1st | Steve Luke | Michigan |
| 184 | 1st | Jake Herbert | Northwestern |
| 197 | 1st | Jake Varner | Iowa State |
| 285 | 1st | Mark Ellis | Missouri |